Step Behind The Stage
Blood Brothers
New Theatre, Peterborough - 25/03/25
Review by Daniel Marshall

The 2024/25 UK tour of Blood Brothers is well under way, opening its five-night residency at Peterborough's New Theatre last night. Written and composed by Willy Russell, the musical remains one of the most widely performed and highly regarded shows of all time.
Blood Brothers explores societal class and the concept of nature versus nurture through the story of fraternal twins separated at birth, one raised poor and one rich. Mickey and Eddie are portrayed by returning cast members Sean Jones and Joe Sleight. Sean Jones, in particular, has become synonymous with Mickey, having been involved with the production for over two decades.
For a show known for its dark tone and dramatic moments, Jones and Sleight brought real comedic relief in the first act. The duo perfectly embodied youthful innocence, often highlighting the blissful naivety of children unaware of the suffering around them. Much of the early hardship rests on the shoulders of Mrs Johnstone, the twins’ birth mother. In this tour, Vivienne Carlyle returns to the role, delivering one of the night’s most heartbreakingly beautiful performances. Her haunting rendition of Easy Terms is truly one of the most moving moments I have ever seen on stage—at least until the second act unfolded.
The story is further enhanced by Seán Keany as the narrator, who breaks the fourth wall and menacingly stalks the characters around the stage, acting as a devilish reminder of their impending fates. Keany’s presence amplifies the drama tenfold, and his vocal performances, including breathtaking duets with Carlyle, create an emotive power duo unlike any other.

The second act brings a noticeable tonal shift. The lighthearted humour of the first act gives way to tense drama, often difficult to watch but impossible to look away from. This shift allowed other actors to take centre stage, pushing the emotional boundaries of their roles. Gemma Brodrick delivered a moving portrayal of Linda’s emotional turmoil, while Sarah Jane Buckley’s depiction of Mrs Lyons’ descent into paranoia was gripping.
Mickey undergoes the most dramatic transformation. The joyous child of the first act becomes a bitter man, frustrated with himself and the world. Sean Jones’ portrayal captures every conceivable emotion, creating a palpable intensity that makes the audience feel like a fly on the wall witnessing life’s most devastating moments. The second act reaches its emotional peak in the closing number, Tell Me It’s Not True. Carlyle leads the song, joined by the full company, delivering a performance that is both soul-stirring and physically heartbreaking. By the final note, there was hardly a dry eye in the house. The cast’s ability to reach such psychological depths night after night is a testament to their skill and endurance.
While much of the production’s brilliance lies with the lead roles, the supporting cast is equally exceptional. From creating humorous interludes to amplifying the heartbreak, every performer contributed to the evening’s impact.
The creative team also deserves high praise. Andy Walmsley’s set design perfectly captures 1950–80s Liverpool with thematic simplicity, allowing the performances to shine. Nick Richinas’ lighting complements this, using focused spotlights for intimate moments and dynamically intensifying during chaotic scenes such as Madman.
With high expectations heading in, the production still exceeded them. This Blood Brothers tour features some of the finest theatrical performances I have ever witnessed and is a must-see for theatre lovers wherever it tours.
Cast on the Night:
Vivienne Carlyle – Mrs Johnstone
Seán Keany – Narrator
Sean Jones – Mickey
Joe Sleight – Eddie
Sarah Jane Buckley – Mrs Lyons
Gemma Brodrick – Linda
James Ledsham – Sammy
Graeme Kinniburgh – Mr Lyons
Alex Harland – Policeman/Teacher
Chloe Polé – Donna Marie/Miss Jones
Dominic Gore – Postman/Bus Conductor
Cameron Patmore – Perkins
Jess Smith – Brenda
