Step Behind The Stage

The Shawshank Redemption

New Theatre, Peterborough - 24/02/26
Review by Alex King

Photo Credit: Jack Merriman

Alongside Stephen King’s tapestry of iconic horror stories and characters sits a story quite different from the rest but just as riveting. Made famous by the 1994 Frank Darabont film, many people are unaware that Stephen King was responsible for the original source material, with the extended title of Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption. Yet this story has been critically acclaimed for decades despite its small and unlikely beginning. After first premiering on stage in 2009, Owen O’Neill and Dave Johns’ adaptation is once again touring the UK throughout the first half of 2026.

Set within the cold, confining walls of Shawshank State Prison, excellently reflected by Gary McCann’s set design, the story takes place over 20 years. It follows the self-proclaimed innocent Andy Dufresne as he navigates both his fellow inmates and those in authority. Though the cast is responsible for much of the storytelling, the production and crew play a significant role in bringing the world to life. Recognisable songs such as ‘Walk the Line’ and ‘Twist and Shout’ help portray the passage of years. This is further enhanced by Andy Graham’s sound design, which allows the music to feel both diegetic and symbolic of time. Additionally, lighting designer Chris Davey utilises shadows and light to create imposing silhouettes of antagonists, while also showing warm glows of sunlight that feel just out of reach. This further deepens the trapped feeling experienced by the characters.

The cast of 12 all deliver in their performances throughout the play. The chemistry between them and every relationship feels genuine and built upon years together. Through alliances and enemies alike, there is a strong sense of history between inmates that is clearly on display in group scenes. Secondary characters lack no depth compared to the protagonists and even in the background feel alive. Whether it is Ashley D Gayle’s piercing cackle as Rooster, Samarge Hamilton’s sweet sincerity as Rico, or Graham Elwell’s insecure yet frighteningly powerful Hadley, every character feels fully realised. This brings the story together even more. I felt this was further supported by the costume design, also by Gary McCann. Despite the uniformity of the prisoners’ clothing, each identity felt distinct. Andy’s personality is emphasised by his rolled down sleeves and tucked in shirt. The more relaxed fit of long-term inmates such as Bogs and Red reflects the time they have spent there. The subtle differences in what could have been a very standard set of costumes are an excellent display of McCann’s skill.

Of the secondary characters, I want to give special mention to Kenneth Jay’s portrayal of Brooksie, the elderly librarian inmate. What begins as a depiction of a mild-mannered old-timer becomes a heartbreaking yet gripping performance of a man who knows nothing but how to be a prisoner. In the second half, Jay holds both the audience and the prison in his hand as he delivers a tragic monologue that persists in reality to this day.

Photo Credit: Jack Merriman

Of our three primary characters, first we have Joe McFadden as Andy Dufresne. McFadden’s physicality is what struck me most. His posture and body language allow many other characters to stand over him, making Andy feel even more like a fish out of water. As time goes on and Andy develops, McFadden’s portrayal becomes more confident. However, he never loses that slight smallness, which creates an almost underdog quality to the performance. You feel for him and empathise with his struggle.

Next we have Warden Stammas, portrayed by Bill Ward. As the most senior officer in the prison, Stammas is presented in a fascinating way. Initially, he appears to be someone who, while clearly having his own agenda, respects people as long as they respect him. This eventually gives way to a far viler nature. Yet you do not quite believe it at first, and that is entirely intentional. Bill Ward excels at portraying a two-faced, manipulative and deeply evil man. From his over-enunciation of “staTe senaTe” to his ever-calm yet all-powerful presence over the prison, Warden Stammas is written to be despised. Ward succeeds in every facet.

Last, but far from least, is Ben Onwukwe’s return to the role of Ellis ‘Red’ Redding following the 2022 tour. Red is the anchor of the story, serving as narrator for the audience, smuggler for the inmates and beating heart of the narrative. As Red, Onwukwe is absolutely captivating. Opening the show, he delivers a monologue that immediately draws you into his world-weary prison existence while still maintaining optimism in his own way. When not speaking, Onwukwe’s expressions, whether in the background or as part of his narration, are consistently compelling to watch. Red is a difficult role to portray. Anyone familiar with the film will naturally draw comparisons to Morgan Freeman’s famous performance. However, Ben Onwukwe stands firmly on his own merit and delivers a character who is humorous and wise, beaten down yet still looking upward. As well as opening the play, he is responsible for closing it in an extended monologue that delivers in every way. I do not wish to discredit the other performers, as they all do an incredible job in bringing the play to life. However, Ben Onwukwe is a standout within an already strong ensemble.

Whether you are familiar with the original novella, the 1994 film or coming to the story completely fresh, I strongly recommend seeing this production if you have the opportunity. The script is tight and balances humour within a brutal and emotional narrative. The direction is striking and memorable. The cast elevate one another throughout. While the title carries a strong legacy, this adaptation more than stands on its own credibility and deserves to be recognised as such.

Please be advised that this play contains depictions of rape, references to suicide and offensive language.

The show is running at Peterborough New Theatre until Saturday 28 February, so be sure to head down if you’re local, or visit the tour page for more information on the rest of the UK dates.


Cast on the Night:

Joe McFadden – Andy Dufresne
Ben Onwukwe – Ellis ‘Red’ Redding
Bill Ward – Warden Stammas
Graham Elwell – Hadley
Ashley D Gayle – Rooster
Jeffrey Harmer – Entwistle
Kyle Harrison-Pope – Tommy Williams
Kenneth Jay – Brooksie
Sean Kingsley – Bogs Diamond
Samarge Hamilton – Rico
Aein Nasseri – Nelson
Owen Oldroyd – Dawkins

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.